357 vs 44 magnum ballistics
I chose a .357mag for that purpose, and don't regret it at all. in. It can only be used in open carry. and Marlin 1894 (.44 Mag.) .44 Mag., 240 at 1760 fps, 6.5 lb. at 100 yds. When it come to a head-to-head comparison, theres a world of difference between these two brother cartridges. The remaining important factor to consider is recoil. The hole of course will be a bit smaller and present less bullet surface. That is 549 foot pounds of energy from a .44 diameter bullet. .35 Rem., 200 at 2050 fps, 7.0 lb. 10mm vs. 357 Mag Muzzle Energy. There's been a few different 45 rounds through the years so here's my opinions; these are mine alone and there's a lot of leeway here. at 100 yds. 38 wad cutters and 357 mag. As can be seen, the true rifle cartridges bring substantially more game killing power to the table. .357 Mag., 158 at 1830 - 110 lbs. (The "Maximum Optimum Ranges for Big Game" table on the Tables, Charts and Lists page is based on the OGW formula, but expressed another way.) In 1969 Marlin recognized the demand and reintroduced the Model 1894, chambered for .44 Special/.44 Magnum. at 100 yds., 156 lbs. This is true even for those seeking a traditional, Western style lever action rifle, since the .30-30 was actually used in rifles during the final years of the 19th Century and neither revolver cartridges can make that claim. To start, here are velocity figures for some representative factory loads, taken from the Winchester and Remington ammo catalogs. RIFLE BALLISTICS. The .357 on the other hand can get really moving with a hot loaded JHP and perform rather stunning feats. They can be a lot of fun to shoot, particularly when plinking with reduced loads, and the whole point of the shooting sports is enjoyment. Find in-stock .357 Magnum ammunition and sort by price, brand, seller, review and more. at 200 yds. Furthermore, the muzzle energy of a .357 Magnum round averages out to 530 ft-lb, while a .41 Remington Magnum round averages out to about 760 ft-lb. The .44 special on the other hand will give you 1032 for 591 foot pounds. The 10mm was originally developed to create a semi-auto cartridge that emulated the ballistic and terminal performance of the 357 Magnum. The popularity of the practice waned when the frontier became settled and ammunition became readily available almost everywhere. In a hunting load that is great, in a defense load not so much. at 100 yds. After all, no matter how much power a bullet possesses, it must hit the target to do any damage. Here are the cross-sectional areas of these bullets in square inches..308" - 0.0745 sq. Just remember, with big game hunting loads, a .44 Magnum carbine kicks as hard as a .30-30 and is less effective. From top to bottom these rifles are: Marlin Model 336 (.30-30 and .35 Rem. The sport of cowboy action shooting has also contributed to the popularity of such rifles. At longer ranges the advantage of the rifle cartridges is even greater. On the other hand, the .357 Magnum can prove to be a vastly more emphatic killer than some of our more recent low velocity tactical rifle cartridge designs although the latter have superior trajectories. I really enjoyed shooting and hunting with that light, handy, low recoil carbine and I have long been a fan of the .357 Magnum cartridge. or .44 Mag. rifle cartridges, since they can be had in similar firearms. With the same hold a 150 grain .30-30 bullet would land within an inch of the exact point of aim and kill that deer in its tracks. It should. The 44 Magnum rounds have poor concealment value. ME, 966 ft. lbs. at 100 yds., 56 lbs. Lets take a look at a few numbers first. These are made in various places, including Italy and Brazil. This would place it in the middle of the pack for .30-30 ballistics, at least within 100 yards, at a cost about equal to premium .30-30 ammo. .30-30, 150 at 2390 fps, 7.0 lb. Contact me here. The research that went into this article has made it obvious to me that, for the modern hunter, there is little practical advantage to buying a rifle chambered for a pistol cartridge if a similar rifle can be had in a true rifle cartridge. These men were generally not recreational shooters or sport hunters, but working men who viewed their guns as tools. .30-30, 150 at 2390: +2.9" at 100 yds., -0.6" at 200 yds., 225 yds. I am assuming that an average buck standing broadside measures about 18" from the top of his back to the bottom of his brisket. The 44 Special will not do anything a .357 Magnum can do. The cost of practice ammo is a consideration though, so getting into handloading is a good idea if you do a lot of shooting. I was asked why someone would consider a .44 special over the .357 magnum for carry or general defense. How many of those foot pounds is lost keeping that .357 trucking along after it exits? The .357 Magnum in the neat Marlin 1884C carbine is the least powerful of our comparison cartridges and also kicks the least, by a wide margin. .357 Mag., Win. As these sectional density numbers indicate, the rifle calibers have a big advantage in SD, and thus theoretical penetration, over the handgun calibers. The .357 Mag is smaller compared to the .44 Mag. However, by about 1950, shooters with .357 Magnum revolvers started buying old Winchester Model 92 and Marlin 1894 carbines and having them re-barreled for the .357 revolver cartridge. Velocity, of course, has a big influence on both kinetic energy and trajectory and it is obvious from these figures that the true rifle cartridges have a big advantage in velocity. The mainstream shooting world had moved on. I would conclude by suggesting that if a rifle in a centerfire handgun caliber appeals to you, by all mean go for it. The amount of energy the target retains is what it is all about. Shooting became predominately a recreational activity and most sport hunters did not spend such extended time periods in the field. This isnt the case for the .44 Magnums parent, the .44 Special. HANDGUN BALLISTICS. Now the .357 might be a bit much according to some folks for self defense, as it is known to go through something and keep on going out the other side. Cartridge Type: HandgunHeight: 1.29\"Width: 0.44\"Average FPS: 1294Average Energy: 528Average Gr: 142Recoil: 0.89Power Rank: 3.68 of 7The .357 Magnum may be the ultimate handgun cartridge produced within the last 100 years. Now with a .44 you tend to get heavier ammo out of the chute. Complete 44 special ammunition ballistics Chart. It was fairly common on the American western frontier in the 19th Century. Imported copies of historical Winchester lever action rifles and the Colt Lightning pump gun are available in a variety of revolver cartridges. The Winchester Model 1892 (calibers .218 Bee, .25-20, .32-20, .38-40 and .44-40), the most popular of the rifles designed for handgun cartridges, remained in the line until 1941, as its sales slowly melted away. It was originally designed and released in 1934 by Phil Sharpe, and Elmer Keith. ), Marlin 1894C (.357 Mag.) Browse and buy .357 Magnum ammo online easily with Ammohead. Some are even purchased by deer hunters who think that the larger diameter bullets thrown by a .44 Magnum carbine are more effective than the faster, but smaller caliber, bullets from more traditional deer cartridges, such as the .30-30 Winchester and .35 Remington. MPBR, .44 Mag., 240 at 1760: +2.6" at 100 yds., -11.6" at 200 yds., 159 yds. 920 foot pounds with a screaming 1,691 fps. Just by firing it out of a longer barrel, a.357 Magnum will meet or even well exceed the muzzle energy of a.44 Magnum from a handgun..357 Magnum vs.44 Magnum Ballistic Gel Tests Okay, lets move on to the terminal ballistics. Usually, it is fired by big revolvers. .35 Rem., Rem. While I do not believe that any system of estimating killing power is completely accurate, OGW does correlate pretty well with the experience of many knowledgeable hunters. You arent going to get magnum performance out of most .38 Special ammo. 356 foot pounds can be expected with a velocity of 1,056 fps. .30-30, 150 at 2390 - 1902 ft. lbs. rifle - 6.5 ft. lbs. vs. .44 Mag.) Winchester has also produced limited runs of Model 92's (calibers .357 Mag., .44-40, .44 Mag., and .45 Colt . A factory loading will give you something more like 1261 for 511 foot pounds though. 38 special. rifle - 11.3 ft. lbs. I shoot 38 short. The .357 Other than wildcats, the 357 magnum was the most powerful handgun in the world until the 44 magnum in 1955. Furthermore, the muzzle energy of a .357 Magnum round averages out to 530 ft-lb, while a .45 Colt (LC Long Colt) round averages out to about 500 ft-lb. However, I quickly discovered that, depending on the situation, it made sense to carry either the revolver or the carbine, but not both. As the neck is longer in the .44 Mag, it can hold bullets of .35 Rem., 200 at 2080 - 294 lbs. We understand price matters. Henry on December 04, 2018: I have a 357 maximum but I dont reload can I buy a box. 45 colt has never in it's history been the most powerful handgun. Cartridge Type: Height: 1.29" Width: 0.44" Average FPS: 1737 Average Energy: 1105 Average Gr: 165 Recoil: 1.3 *Casing image above is an artist rendering and not a real photo of .357 Magnum (Rifle Data) Ballistics cartridge.