After all, it is a cartridge that was introduced in the Colt SAA in 1873. 45 long colt versus 357 magnum recoil Out of a 4 inch barrel, with good SD loads, which caliber has less perceived recoil? Had my 50th .357 out today, and with .357/125s it's a pussycat. Given the larger case head of the .45 Colt, 23,000 psi Tier 2 .45 Colt loads would not be healthy for an 1873 and 32,000 psi Tier 3 loads would probably break one in a hurry. What is the advantage of .45 … Been looking at the case hardened Henry Big Boys and need some help on caliber choice. It consists of the SS109, SS110, and SS111 cartridges. I am going to assume that the .45 colt will kick more right? I shoot a NM Convertible .45 in LC with 250 Keiths and 8.5 Unique a fair amount, and it has noticeably more recoil than the above gun, or so it seems to me. Which is easer to find .45 colt or .357 ammo? I am kinda new to CAS and all my guns are chambered to shoot .45 Colt. then there's the traditional 250gr moving about 900fps. .45 Colt lever is very manageable, with easy follow up. For 357 Magum the max pressure is 35,000 psi. Now, about .45 "Long" Colt: Yes, .45 Colt can be hand-loaded to very powerful levels, depending upon the inherent strength of the gun from which it will be shot. I am trying to decide on a good nightstand/home defense revolver. Watch and let the results demonstrate the merits of each caliber choice. Also isnt .357 ammo cheaper? I under stand that the 357 is the smaller more energy transfer vs the slow bigger hole of the 45 colt. Unless you need the greater power of the .44 Magnum the .357 is a good choice for a field gun. Between the .45 Long Colt vs 45 ACP cartridges, there’s over two and a half centuries of combined history. Recoil in the shorty (4 5/8ths) blued Blackhawk in .45 Colt is minimal with Cowboy loads. With a 2 inch barrel it would be used for SD. The .45 ACP cannot be relied on to bring down medium sized game animals like deer where as the .357 Magnum (with the right bullets and load) is a renowned deerslayer. .357 mag vs .45 colt. Please note, the following information reflects the estimated average ballistics for each caliber and does not pertain to … One way to tame the recoil of the 357 Magnum is by switching the grips to the Hogue Monogrips. 45 Long Colt is very versatile if you want to make it that way. I do reload both calibers and like the 357/38 for competitions. Hullo The Campfire. They really work well for me when shooting heavy loads in my SP 101. Then you can find some that send a 300gr bullet about 1,300 fps. I have wheelguns in both calibers (couple of Ruger RedHawks) and reload for .38/.357 and .45 Colt/.454 Casull. When I shoot reduced recoil .45 Colt loads, I use Cowboy 45 Special case, (available from Starline), or a Schofield case. Im comparison to .357 Mag loads in the NV, its a wash. Its a slower recoil but its something you perceive rather than see or feel in a concrete fashion. But, no, .45 Colt is not normally commercially loaded to a power level that approximates .357 Magnum. Buy, Sell, and Trade your Firearms and Gear. Much like .45-70, .30-06 and other cartridges, the .45 Colt — aka .45 Long Colt — is an old cartridge design, dating back more than a century. I also have lever action rifles to match the pistols. Well, it depends. .45 vs .357 mag vs 10mm auto ... the us found in their study that 250 45 did the same (45 colt) ... heavy handgun with rather stiff recoil/slide return springs that not everyone can manhandle. I also can't seem to get away from the idea that a 255 grain bullet will impart more damage than the 357 round. The problem is that a .45 Colt cartridge may find itself in an old, weak pistol. Significantly more. Especially for handloading, the 45LC can be loaded with very light hitting cowboy action shooting loads, but also with heavy fast loads that exceed the capabilities of factory 44 magnum ammunition. If your comfortable with the added recoil of the 45 Colt, stick with it. I was wondering if I should get the Taurus Judge with 45 long colt, or the ruger sp-101 with 357 magnum. Firearm Discussion and Resources from AR-15, AK-47, Handguns and more! 357 Magnum vs 45 ACP. I know that the grain makes a big difference but if it were a low grain .45 and a high grain .357 would the .45 still overpower? I like the recoil pulse of the 45 colt better than the snap of the 357. Which is more punishing? On the .45 ACP side, most of the guns chambered in this caliber are semi-autos, although a few revolvers chambered for .45ACP, such as the S&W Model 625, do exist. ADD: It's not true that the .45 Colt is more powerful than the .357 magnum. For modern shooters today, they continue to deliver the performance, consistency, and accuracy we expect. [su_heading size=”30″] Which Caliber would you Use in a SHTF Scenario? When first invented, it was propelled by black powder. You'll find rifle data for the .357 Magnum operating at 35,000 psi - with velocities around 1800 fps for 158 gr bullets and 2200 fps for 125 gr bullets in 20" barrels. In this .357 Magnum vs. .45 ACP penetration matchup, which ammo for SHTF? My subjective impression is that, with a well designed stock, recoil velocity above about 10 fps begins to feel like a sharp rap on the shoulder rather than an abrupt push. Free recoil mostly depends upon the weight of the handgun on the one hand, and the mass of the powder, projectile and the muzzle velocity on the other. Personally, I lean towards the heavier .45 Colt, but plenty a deer have been taken with .357 (some nice new heavy loads out … Therefore, it's a fundamental “hotter" round. So the 45lc (long colt) round is a larger round and was originally designed to be used in both rifles and pistols as a blackpowder round. The 45 Colt has slightly more potential, _if_ you handload for it,but in factory loads the difference is negligible. These can be measured or computed empirically and have been for this recoil table. The 357 is the more versatile, and with 38 spl. Published on 2018 2019 by jhines. At the time is was introduced the .357 mag was the most powerful handgun ever made. 45 long colt vs 38 special recoil. I have the Vaquero in 45 Colt and like it for certain targets and overall just safety outdoors as the size and potential of the 45 Colt. I know that the 357 imparts energy and causes a big temporary wound cavity but the 255 grain should cause a … Two seperate shops have recomended a 45 Colt over a 357 Mag to me for a hunting/shooting gun. The following ammunition cartridge ballistics information and chart can be used to approximately compare .38 Special vs .45 Colt (LC Long Colt) ammo rounds. Recoil? I looked at the tarus model 450 as its the only small light weight 45 colt DA I could find. Then there's the cowboy loads that send a 250gr bullet 650-750 fps. I was wondering if someone could please help as to what loads they use in the .45 cal shells for Cowboy Action shooting. 357 magnum or 45 long colt. What is the real world difference between the 158 grain 1250 fps and the 45 colt doing about 850-900 fps? The maximum chamber pressure for in spec 45 ACP ammunition is 21,000 psi. Firearm Discussion and Resources from AR-15, AK-47, Handguns and more! There are a few .357 semi-autos, such as the Desert Eagle, but they are relatively rare. Useful for self defense, and hunting. The .357 … Just got myself a Bond Arms Snake Slayer 4 barrel in 45 Long Colt/410 gauge. Recoil energy determines how hard the blow to the hand feels and recoil velocity determines how abrupt the blow feels. Some loads generate over 600. Which is the more punishing round? It is a really good all around useful cartridge. Buy, Sell, and Trade your Firearms and Gear. I am looking at recoil, muzzle, blast, penetration soft and hard (barrier), wound channel etc. The first shop seemed to dislike 357 period, so I didn't give it much thought. I would be interested in finding a good load that would do the job and not break my wrist. These cartridges have seen it all, from casual target shooting to all-out war. For me the full power 125 grain loads have more felt recoil than any thing I have fired out of my 45 ACP. .357 even more so. The second shop provided more insight to … Typically, .357 Magnum guns are revolvers. Recoil is mild even with full power .357 loads. That's the Cowboy 45 Special. Do not forget that gun weight is a crucial factor in the recoil equation, inversely proportional to recoil. For all you 45 shooters out there what cartridge do you use in your revolvers and why? the easiest to find ammo and components for. It seems that many .45 Colt shooters actually shoot .45 Schofield or .45 Cowboy Special in their revolvers. The average .45 Colt load produces 370 foot-pounds of muzzle energy, and the average ME of the .357 is 550 ft-lbs. The .38 Special was introduced in 18 as a military service cartridge because the .38 Long Colt had insufficient stopping power against the wooden shields of Moros during the Philippine-American War. If one is OK with the wieght, springs and learns to handle the recoil, the 10mm is a VERY serious and effective weapon. In fact, much of today’s .45 Colt ammunition still is since one of the most popular uses for it […] Recoil compared to 357 is very variable with the 45 long colt. We have a fair number of people who shoot .45 Colt in the rifle. There's .45 LC that pushes a 200gr bullet about 875 fps. I am leaning towards the .45 Colt, since I can load it HOT for the Super Redhawk and the Henry should be good to go for all but the “stupid” stuff. .45 Long Colt is a very versatile round. While recoil energy determines how hard the blow to the shoulder feels, recoil velocity determines how abrupt the blow to the shoulder feels. Thanks Mate Kind Regards Capt Starlight Im going to get a new revolver and im very new to revolvers, i only own rifles. There is another cartridge case that can be fired in the 45 Colt. so I have been looking at 45 colt loads. But, I still load 200gr for the rifle, in a .45 Colt or a .45 Schofield case because the Schofieds with a 160s are too short in a '66. -David The longer tube of the rifle will give you higher velocity than the .357 gets in a revolver. But it's a pretty chunky little gun with a lot of steel in it. Both are fine calibers, and able to take deer out to 100 yards or so. The C45S case is the same length and volume as the 45ACP but with a 45 Colt rim. I was interested in a 357 because of less recoil and cheaper ammo. I use a 160 bullet.