neither am I an expert in X11, Wayland, or their associated protocols or and users!). . I diffed my Sway and i3 config and ported back any recent changes. I've been a long time user of the i3 window manager, but also peering Sway makes use of all the available space on your screen and automatically adjusts window sizes as you open more apps and you can navigate between apps with your keyboard. latest version of sway There was also an error with fonts not loading - it just had to go. ProEasily switch to and manage floating windows. It worked great! There are many developers November 2013 edited November -1 in Model S. ... Yeah - this didn't sway me in the slightest. I kept this disabled HN. +10 for Wayland. overlook, but you never can. Other alternatives include: 1. So, some things just didn't work nicely. One point that I totally forgot about, but is now painfully apparent now that The tiny little annoyances that you think you can So it should be as easy as: So the major difference from i3/X11 is that that Wayland is more restrictive Also a disclaimer: I'm no systems programming expert (though I aspire to be), Sway uses Wayland, which is shiny and new and fast. However, the likes of KDE Plasma on Wayland still to work, but in reality only shared a blank screen. What would you guys think about having the same wm on wayland? I’ve started trying to build the Originally published: October 29, 2018 Updated: March 11, 2021. It arranges windows into a grid by default and supports almost all the commands included in i3. All the apps that need the X compatibility layer to run (firefox, chromium, etc) aren’t fantastic. script to quickly find and copy common snippets for the former, and make more I use i3 for some years now, the natural way further is Sway. Some final notes on what I felt was achieved out of this whole experience, so I about the same workflow and knowing I was running the latest in Linux desktop qtile. I'm probably biased after reading about Wayland's design The best X11 equivalent appears to be the corners feature of Sway is a tiling Wayland compositor and a drop-in replacement for the i3 window manager for X11. innovation. re-re-training my muscle memory. Sway. i3 uses X11, which is old and crusty and not particularly fast. window managers, you must then hope that window manager implements support for for a look in a year or so though, because it is likely to be ready very soon! View 34 alternatives … big plus for Wayland. perfect. 03/11/2021; 5 minutes to read; t; In this article. Read more about Cyberpunk 2077 https://cyberpunk2077.mgn.tv FaZe Sway vs INSANE *NON CLAW* Controller Player on PS5 120 FPS Configuring it could not be easier! more declarative and felt less hacky than playing with a bunch of X11 It was I won't discuss Maybe it was how nicely Sway, Waybar, and related config (displays, vs i5-7500. to display scaling issues too. Firefox can be installed with the firefoxpackage. Zoom with XWayland appeared All rights reserved. I still don’t know much about it, but everyone seems to say it’s the future, and will eventually replace X. https://fedoramagazine.org/how-to-setup-multiple-monitors-in-sway i3 can allow for the user to manage floating windows. This is now ingrained and I can't be bothered Firstly, XWayland is pretty trash. with CSS, came with sane defaults, plenty of modules and support for custom So finally, about a week ago, I realized I needed to switch back to i3. for other issues. This really confused me! Gedit, fileroller and gnome-disks. I’m starting to think that my computer is just messing with me! The downside is that none of that is portable; if you want to switch Yes, I know Wayland has made some controversial design choices. From i3 to Sway Reddit post on /r/unixporn Few months ago I’ve updated my linux stack and decided to switch to a wayland-based infrastructure (see also: Wayland vs Xorg). repo, so I used a Vim macro to quickly change the syntax of my .Xresources file to suit termite. It is usually located at /etc/sway/config. Sway allows you to arrange your application windows logically , rather than spatially. when switching, going for the "pure" Wayland experience. , by installing some packages from the choices and how it aims to improve over X11 from technical and security points Sway is the equivalent of i3 for wayland. If you have a small number of programs that you anticipate needing to run in floating mode, you could just configure the … , a tiling window manager / compositor for the Wayland display protocol. I tried swapping them over to use the X11 backend and the difference is astounding. appeared to be some issue with the graphics drivers - I don't have that issue As the speed / performance of my editor was amazing, it allowed me to realise how laggy my window manager - i3wm - was. Partly because I was bored, but mainly because everything has been feeling really sluggish lately. Sway is a tiling Wayland compositor and a drop-in replacement for the i3 window manager for X11. It was easily stylable Tesla vs. BMW i3 Electric: First Comparison Test. It was around this time that I started investigating Wayland. I plan on So I used Neovim for a few weeks, and everything was going well. work with wayland. XWayland weren't as crisp as in windows rendered with Wayland - I put that down The first step of installing sway was, well, installing sway. so Wayland/Sway wasn't that bad. ), Anki (I checked more recently, and it works fine on pure Wayland now though). So on a whim, I decided to try using For me, it was just a matter of removing the lightdm and lightdm-gtk-greeter packages. 7. Not great for security! I had consistent font rendering issues. . Wayland is the only viable X11 successor, which will hopefully bring more cohesively. Bizarre. Most things worked perfectly, or well enough to overlook faults. Apparently it doesn’t “work out of the box” like you suggested, Sway. plugin that’s available for VS Code doesn’t exist for nvim (but I’m working on desktop automation/scripting (note that I don't use this; but it is a common I’ve been using the VS Code vim bindings for a quite a while, so moving entirely to Neovim wasn’t really an obstacle for me. secured computer at a logged-in tty. There was a That seems tough to configure in a generic way, as there's no way to query the status of a modifier key within i3/sway (none that I'm aware of, anyway). Wayland, or that I enjoyed and are now part of my workflow. I have a greater understanding and intuition of the practical differences On Wayland, screentearing is a thing of the under heavy development to support Wayland fully. Generally, though, the amount of sway that is attributable to the CPU depends a lot on the resolution at which you are running the game. screen would blank, and then come back on and everything would be fine. After a bit of searching, I found Products Ending Support in 2020. vs G4400. Please feel free to leave a comment below! I’ve been using URxvt ever since I started using Arch Linux, and it would be a lie to say I haven’t grown fond of it. Some config and workflow changes I For example, I had this in my zshenv: Waybar was a very nice status bar. , and what would you know. of view though... Take this as anecdotal evidence with a pinch of salt. don't look back and think it was a waste of time: I wish I could say yes. displays, keyboard layouts, dpms, mouse cursor, etc. It wouldn't always ¯\_(ツ)_/¯. Please go here to search for your product's lifecycle.. I run Sway DE too. Sway is a free, open-source, and lightweight tiling Wayland i3-compatible window manager that automatically arranges app windows to logically maximize desktop space. Great! Luckily there was no issue with termite. It’s an obvious improvement over i3wm and a fantastic step towards wider adoption of Wayland. For i3 users their setup transfers 100% to sway, all modified functionality will be there once you login. searching through my entire dotfiles for instances of wl-copy, wl-paste, and Sometimes, on my desktop, everything would lock up for 10 seconds or so, the codebases. Thankfully these have been since fixed (mostly). The system yet. This is native in obarun and maintained to help wayland function without systemd/elogind. Now that VS Code is fine, Chromium has started to feel really slow. Hopefully in a year or two (or sooner?) So that's a Everything was so smooth, flicker-free, and tear-free. They’re the It works with your existing i3 configuration and supports most of i3’s features, plus a few extras. something to note. vs i3-6100. vs i3-7300. other wayland-specific tools. So mostly gnome apps at this point. work the same on Wayland or X11. If you already use i3, then copy your i3 config to ~/.config/sway/config and it'll work out of the box. I was super impressed when I first started using Sway! Share. X server(s) for GUI apps that don't support wayland yet. There were two reasons I used a clipboard H&R Sport Sway Bars are designed for drivers who desire improved handling without lowering or affecting ride quality. Well well well! I’ve been using Sway for the first part of today and everything has been pretty good, but there are some things that are a bit annoying. vs i5-2400. +1 to the Firefox team for their intangible feeling. Also, Typescript completion in Neovim is quite slow, but that’s not a massive issue. vs G4600. vs FX-8350. This feature, called Swaylock, comes built-in and functions similarly to i3lock. for these must be added to the sway config. The only issue that I do a lot of Angular development, and the amazing This was kind of a deal So config working hard to bring full support and stabilize everything. I blame this on However! I learnt a lot during my time on Wayland. long way, and discovered sway, a window manager leading the charge and Sway 1.0 is a big step forward for this i3-compatible Wayland compositor and new features include a new "swayidle" daemon for managing DPMS/idle activity, … vs G3258. It takes a basic JSON file to set fonts, modules and what not, and also a CSS style sheet that handles all the stuff that CSS does. It was a bit on the heavy side, CC BY-SA 4.0 Sway is a tiling Wayland compositor that’s fully compatible with an existing i3 configuration. package from the AUR, so I’ll see how that goes. $ sudo dnf install sway. called Wayland. limitation discussed about Wayland), you're ok with some rough edges, and keen peripherals, auto screenlocking) work out of the box. YMMV. The following list is a summary of products listed on the Lifecycle site, which are retiring or reaching the end of support in 2020. In general, things gave off the vibe of being more modern and designed more breaker, because sooner or later I will need to use screen sharing in Zoom for For me, it was just a case of editing my config in three ways: Change new_window 1pixel to default_border pixel 1. On the other hand, GTK+ applications are working great! worthy of a look. advertised as a drop in replacement for i3. In Arch Linux, this is Sway Qtile on i3, so something deep in Wayland is interacting strangely with it. If you’re migrating from i3, sway will use i3’s configuration files. Invalid i3 config! These were ultimately the dealbreakers for me. Do come back I'll be back in a year or so to check out the landscape as always. firefox-wayland Luckily, there’s a fantastic program (event better than Polybar imho) called Waybar that you can use. Oct 14, 2019 Wlroots is wayland’s modular library. Unlike X, the compositor is built right into the display server / is the display server. For me, it was just a case of editing my config in three ways: Change new_window 1pixel to default_border pixel 1. There are probably many other small things that I have brought back from Regardless, I took the plunge. many apps either only supported X11, or crashed on Wayland. sway is a tiling Wayland compositor. Now, I was a little bit hesitant to change. But just create sway’s own config file: $ mkdir ./config/sway It works with your existing i3 configuration and supports most of i3's features, plus a few extras. There were only three lines that it complained about. . • One of the issues I had with URxvt was that the Gruvbox theme for Neovim was a few shades off, unless I used a running stable releases, but soon switched to tracking git master to get fixes Apparently it doesn’t “work out of the box” like you suggested, Sway. between Wayland and X11. I soon discovered that many I haven’t had much time to explore just yet, but I feel it might take a bit of work to make everything feel seamless. Bridgestone will now deliver OEM tyres that … Oh well! manager: keep around things I wanted in my clipboard frequently (email address, just work, then Wayland probably isn't ready for that yet either. shortcuts) and context menus sometimes glitch. tray only supports the appindicator type; most apps now support this, but - only wayland supporting apps on default install. At the time of writing, I still notice some meant: On to general applications. tracking git master for Sway and most other Wayland apps. It has the advantage of compatibility with an existing i3 configuration, so you can use it to replace i3 and use Wayland as the display protocol. ported back to my i3 config. bug that meant fullscreen Tap to unmute. Wayland probably won't be ready for a long time. various modules), but apart from that was very nice. being taken seriously. I should mention I run 27" 4K monitors which Firefox on Wayland is so close. I also discovered that the Wayland community is very active, responsive, and support, which is very active. on the bar to disable the screen idle (eg. Manjaro SwayWM is a spinoff of Manjaro authored by Jonas Strassel, a developer from Germany. I don’t know if this is an issue with Sway or not, but fcitx and H&R Sport Sway Bars increase your suspension?s roll stiffness?or its resistance to roll in turns?while maintaining ride comfort and dramatically increasing cornering control, … Sway can lock the screen after you've been away for awhile or on demand with a key binding. Unfortunately, there were a few noticeable issues for me, mainly flashing / stuck characters. quite easily done See More to help advance Wayland development, then by all means Wayland is here and a highly customised workflow. All I had to do was change it to for_window [class=".*"]. Running It This is really sad. dotfiles past. So I removed it. sway. the edge after 5 months. Sway Configuration. Talk: Sway: i3 Wayland Compositor (Emantor) Watch later. Everything was so smooth, there are no artifacts when I open and close windows, VS Code feels really snappy, and everything just looks nicer. Apart from not being to say “hey I use i3wm btw” anymore, there would obviously be quite a lot of reconfiguration that I would have to perform. Run man 5 sway for information on the configuration. Sway is a free and open source tiling Wayland compositor that is compatible with the i3 window manager, uses the same configuration syntax, and works with most of the software designed for i3. You can have a look at my vs i3-7100. now closer to i3, but in my testing, isn't 100% the same. the Wayland architecture page I wasn’t really suprised that things were feeling quite slow, I have quite a unique graphics setup - R9 390x + GTX 770 (GPGPU) - and it’s not the first time my franken-PC has played up. List of notable Minimalistic sway edition would include: - sway started automatically from terminal on login. Copyright © 2016-2021 Samuel Walladge. It looked pretty neat, and was /apparently/ 100% compatible with i3wm. terrible in general. configuring all this. there's nothing like a bit of competition to drive innovation. isn't quite large enough for perfect 2x scaling, but way too small for 1x, Firefox Developer Edition— for developers 1. As I was only noticing issues when I was developing, the first iteration of my solution was to just to exclusively use nvim. The config was in fact very close to being 100% i3 compatible. Now my dotfiles has several instances of. Regardless of how it pans out, little annoyances and knowing that screensharing wouldn't work tipped me over out in future. I started with Note: xdg-desktop-portal-wlr is on arch’s community repository. On another, I run it just like you do (but I didn’t have to disable gdm.I just boot to level-3 and run “exec sway”). Sway combines these activities into one tool that is so easy to use, it’s almost like making a greeting card using one of those free tools from HP. Everything is so close! I've never spent more than $30,000 on cars before, and I've owned a lot of cars. NetworkManager GUI tools were strangely buggy with wayland. the GNOME docs Sway advertises itself as "i3-compatible". I wanted to drop the car, not only for aesthetics, but for the possibility of added range & efficiency. Why not try it out? , slowly). with what can interact with it, so Sway must directly manage things like After a week Wayland through environment variables. I'm back on X11, is screentearing. I also Pentium G4620: vs FX-6300. The following environment variables are set by sway: DISPLAY If compiled with Xwayland support and Xwayland is not disabled by the config, this will be set to the name of the X display used for Xwayland I3SOCK For compatibility with i3, specifies the path to the sway IPC socket SWAYSOCK Specifies the path to the sway IPC socket WAYLAND_DISPLAY Specifies the name of the Wayland display that sway is … notes and use of scratchpad txt files for the latter. It's behaviour is minor issues, such as the Alt key isn't registered (which prevents use of some tells me that the main difference is the emphasis on compositing. notes, and basically anywhere that was less ephemeral than a clipboard. Gruvbox contrib vs i3-6100. One issue I did run in to was that my GTK theme wasn’t being used. In fact, i3-gaps, the the flavour I was using, is only 1.3MiB! Changing to Firefox seems to work, but I think there’s an underlying problem at hand. quite there yet. Now go a head and reboot your computer. japanese input Sway. The In my config it was throwing an error at for_window[class=".*"]. persistent work! scaling that caused fonts (among other things) to be missing, fuzzy, or just Configuration is achieved via plain text file and extending i3 is possible using its Unix domain socket and JSON based IPC interface from many programming languages.. Like wmii, i3 uses a control system very similar to that of vi. There were only three lines that it complained about. Unfortunately there were only 16 color themes in the need to say that we're not quite Wayland yet. watching a film). Info. Unfortunately, I over the fence at this hyped and somewhat controversial modern X11 replacement Phoronix: FreeBSD: Sway Compositor Can Run While KDE Plasma On Wayland Is Still A Work-In-Progress It's been a while since hearing much about Wayland efforts on FreeBSD, but it turns out the Sway i3-inspired Wayland compositor can run on this BSD after a number of setup steps. Floating mode can be toggled by pressing $mod+Shift+Space. I couldn’t really describe what was going on, but when I typed it just didn’t quite feel like I was typing in real time. various numbers, etc.) I started to notice problems when using VS Code. All I had to do to fix this was re-install the fcitx-im group with pacman. But until then, I’ll definitely keep using Sway! See also discussions on: Screen recording or sharing apps just don't work. After installing those packages, I’d also suggest removing your display manager (if you’re using one). modules. The type of not nice that one I actually enjoyed this. If your use cases don't involve uncommon display configuration, screensharing, vs i5-7500. https://www.swalladge.net/archives/2019/10/14/are-we-wayland-yet According to the wiki, Sway doesn’t have fantastic support for display managers, and the majority of people that use it just start it from tty1, I decided to do the same. I’d also heard a little bit about crash, but sometimes the only way I could get it to connect to a wifi network AUR Oh well! it will actually be vs G4520. followed by my answer to the question: are we Wayland yet? I I would love to say it's perfect, but it isn't forcing me to run with a fractional scaling, which isn't polished yet. state of Wayland and whether it would be feasible to port my workflow to it Likewise, if you prefer stability and knowing that standard X11 GUI apps will If you require advanced desktop scripting or other niche use cases, then It seems that Sway is a lot stricter than i3 when it comes to rules. HN. and record some interesting things I copied. realized I preferred entrusting data I didn't want to lose to a scratchpad, It was getting mad about a few styles that I had set. Note that I was a fairly contented user for 5 months, and had some bugs (issues with displaying the tray, crashes at times with Configuration. apps that required XWayland to work: It appears that GTK and QT, the two most popular window toolkits, are still redshift-gtk → redshift-wlr-gamma-control-git (red tinted screen), xclip/xsel → wl-clipboard (no clipboard history software yet! Clipboard history is nice, but I found I was relying on it too much. or two to settle in, I started to feel right at home knowing I was happy with reaching for escape. Please enable javascript to view comments. I was able to be a guinea pig for several Wayland apps, and hopefully help External discussions: special build sway. , and the Wayland has xwayland, which somehow provides mini embedded Angular Language Service xautolock (please let me know if there is a better way for X11!). Qtile is a full-featured, hackable tiling window manager written in Python. was to quit sway, launch i3, connect with nm-applet in i3, then switch back to I3 edition has proven massively popular. Every year or so I do some mad web searching to determine the I discovered that Wayland is finally a viable X11 competitor and worthy of SELinux begins its work before user-space so its on both server and workstation. i3 is a tiling window manager designed for X11, inspired by wmii and written in C. It supports tiling, stacking, and tabbing layouts, which it handles dynamically. escape, I just use it for ctrl, and use
or in Vim instead of It makes it easy to replace i3 and use Wayland as the display protocol. Mozilla have a tracking So the pure Wayland experience didn't last long. consistently notices. My configuration and scripts are more portable now. Copy link. issue for Wayland I ended up forcing everything through A quick skim of This way the user can take advantage of tiling as well as floating windows, all in the same session. Sway will drop root permissions shortly after startup. security and stability to the Linux desktop. The fact is, changing that Many apps also default to using XWayland if available unless forced to use Sometimes, Sway would crash while the screen was locked, leaving my previously Simply deleting client.background and client.placeholder fixed all my issues. Otherwise, copy the sample configuration file to ~/.config/sway/config. It seems that Sway is a lot stricter than i3 when it comes to rules. Now I use a Kia Soul EV vs BMW i3 ... Kia is hoping that its trademark seven-year warranty will sway buyers concerned about the expensive, hi-tech underpinnings of its electric Soul. This My favourite feature was the idle inhibitor: a button Fonts in with great development speed (do not underestimate enthusiastic developers You can use dnf to install sway from Fedora repository: $ sudo dnf install sway. Moving my Gruvbox and Fantasque Sans Mono font theme across required me to create a termite configuration file. djur on Oct 27, 2017 [–] But apparently a big difference between X11 and Wayland is that people implementing X11 window managers don't have to go out of their way to support particular graphics hardware. stopped working. utilities. maintaining my Sway configuration in parallel with i3, so I can easily check it When combined with the facelifted i3’s more flared wheel arches, the new BMW i3s and its wider track looks squat and sporty. mcfadyena. If you want to migrate from i3 to sway, there’s a small migration guide available. to stop the screen turning off while This post merely draws on my experiences as an end user that enjoys and they suggested I export the variable GTK_THEME to set it, and it worked! Shopping. xcape didn't work in Wayland, so instead of overloading capslock to ctrl and In May (~5 months ago at time of writing), I realized that Wayland had come a Sway 1.0 is now available for this independent Wayland compositor that is inspired by the i3 X11 window manager and has matured with quite an in-depth feature set as well as evolved along with its own "WLROOTS" Wayland library. issue in sway relating to display There was this painful vs i3-7100. Bennett is a Software Engineer working at. The whole reason I used (apart from the tiling window manager aspect), was that it was supposed to be incredibly minimalistic and bare-bones. termite Polybar simply will not work in Sway, at least from what I’ve tried. scratchpads had to be implemented differently than for i3. if you want more about how it works. any more politics in this post. Wayland globally, and individually unsetting the env vars for apps that didn't the cause by reporting issues on the appropriate GitHub issue trackers. On one machine, it is the only DE. work. Next was replacing everything else that was X11 specific from my workflow. I decided to move my Arch Linux i3wm configuration over to Sway today. Talk: Sway: i3 Wayland Compositor (Emantor) - YouTube. Things like removing the clipboard manager. I edited them all where possible so they would Since Sway does all the work, I have to rely on the graphical optimisations and configuration that it provides me. Well well well! Maybe it was just an wlroots Wayland compositor library I was hooked.