Shooting the 44 Special loaded with the 200 grain Speer GDHP into Clear Ballistics Gel from my Charter Arms Bulldog. 44 Magnum: STHP: 210: 729: 1250 . For years, we have heard that handguns are less lethal and less effective for defense than rifles. Although The High Road has attempted to provide accurate information on the forum, The High Road assumes no responsibility for the accuracy of the information. More powder behind the bullet is the purpose of the longer magnum cartridges, such as the .357 and .44 caliber rounds, resulting in the ability to deliver more energy at a greater distance. The .44 Magnum is a potent little cartridge and a great deal of fun to shoot. Actually I dont think I have ever seen a commercially loaded round nose 44 magnum. Today on Kentucky Ballistics we perform a pine board test with 44 Magnum, 454 Casull and 500 S&W Magnum! That is all a very long-winded way to say that if I had to choose between a .44 and a .357 lever action, I donât see any reason not to choose the .44 if the primary purpose is hunting or self-defense. But like all cartridges, the .44 Magnum has its strengths and limitations. Underwood 180 gr XTP fired from 6' Herter's SA through four layers of denim into calibrated 10% gelatin. Ballistic gelatin test of Sig Sauer .44 magnum 240gr V-Crown. Five shot velocity average: 1227fps. I shoot the block at the range and then bring it home to analyze the block and recover the bullets. The .44 Magnum is a potent little cartridge and a great deal of fun to shoot. Barrel length: 3 inches. Thank you! This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register. Our buddies over at The Firearm Blog shoot some 44 magnum Sig Sauer 240 grain V-Crown jacketed hollow point ammo into ballistic gel. Author Topic: Gelatin test results (Read 107824 times) Intercooler. Based on the best tests I could find on the internet (there are few proper ones out there), the .44 Magnum in its full-house guise has excessive penetration for self-defense use against human assailants. â⬢ The .44 Spl. Did the bullet fired through the denim expand less than without the denim? The world has seen enough bloody conflicts to confirm this claim. You can support our work by donating to Open Food Facts and also by using the Lilo search engine. However, I consider the factory 45 Colt cartridge in a double action S&W a fine outdoorsman round and good for self defense as well, with acceptable recoil and muzzle blast. Truthfully the .44 Special was nothing special at itâs inception. In ballistic gelatin tests, the .44 Special round generated a nearly 3-inch diameter wound track and 17 inches of controlled penetration. First, muzzle velocity on both the .357 and .44 with the bullets you named will be around 1400 fps, give or take a little. Autoplay Recommendations. During the test, the chronograph reported errors on several rounds. A logical need for more power might lead to a 454 Casull or 480 Ruger. Test Gun: Smith and Wesson model 65. Win a Dirty Harry 44 Magnum S&W Model 29 Revolver. Since velocity quadruples kinetic energy, it goes as a tie. Discussion in 'Handguns: General Discussion' started by chopinbloc, Aug 25, 2014. Here is a 22 mag gelatin test in 20% gelatin. Ways to Watch: Download CarbonTV on any of your favorite devices. It is made for all, by all, and it is funded by all. Chronograph: PACT 1 XP with inferred sky screens. 10mm Auto vs. 357 Magnum The test subjects: The Glock 29 Gen 4 in 10mm and the Smith & Wesson Model 27 with 3.77 and 4.0 inch barrels respectively. HANDGUN BALLISTICS. Back in the 1980s and 1990s, some ballistics test concluded bone and clothing could clog the cavity of the hollow point and prevent it from expanding. Independent tests of Brenneke projectiles against major competitors showed that some slugs penetrated ballistic gelatin a mere 11.2 inchesâ¦compared to as much as 42.5 inches for Brenneke. ... Our 357 magnum test results were obtained using a Smith & Wesson 640 J-Frame revolver with a 2.125â³ barrel. While gelatin tests are not the final word in how a bullet will perform when it hits live flesh, ... tested the .41 or .44 Magnum. In bare gelatin Keith bullets out penetrated 9mm NATO and .45 ACP hardball, and while the roundnosed FMJ bullets tumbled, the Keith loads with 11 grs. Keep in mind that the length of your ⦠Think again, as the Black Hills HoneyBadger proves to be sweet shooting and crazy tough. 2. Hughston, presented just such a test as her high school science project. While a medium or medium-large frame revolver is still an incredibly effective gun for self-defense inside and outside the home, itâs the smaller âsnubbyâ that gets called on ⦠Continue reading ".38 Snubby Ammo" The 44 Magnum made it through one complete 16â³ gel block and stopped just as it pierced the second block. If you want to subscribe to our monthly newsletter, please submit the form below. Episodes. The rounds were fired from a 4.25″ Smith & Wesson Model 69 Combat Magnum revolver. SIG P320 Ervin testing ballistic gelatin with the Sig Sauer P320 pistol. If I'm sitting down to reload full-power .44 Magnum cases, I use spray lube. Moderator; Sharpshooter; Posts: 7891; 10mm, when you care enough to send only the best!! I've got 3 of these suckers and love 'em all. Usually itâs somebody comparing a 5.56mm to a 9mm. BB: 579.8 fps, 3.7' Impact velocity: 1,663 fps Penetration: 11.8' Retained weight: 154.7 gr Max expansion: 0 This grey area is where .44 Magnum could have an even further advantage over .357 Magnum that is really hard for us to test or demonstrate outside of anecdotal evidence. The test was to show the difference between the two rounds and that was accomplished nicely. 44 Magnum Ammo Downrange Determined to gather that information, I placed a Shooting Chrony chronograph 25 yards downrange just inches away from our initial target. Episodes. Load More Seasons 1. 44 Magnum Ammo Downrange Determined to gather that information, I placed a Shooting Chrony chronograph 25 yards downrange just inches away from our initial target. Cartridges Impact Velocity (ft/sec) Maximum Penetration Depth (inch) Expansion (inch 2) Bullet Weight (grain) Barrel Length (inch) Distance * (feet) Speer: 240gr. The carbines make for useful farm tools and compact hunting rifles while handguns are guaranteed to put an ear to ear grin on any shooters face. False Confessions features our slow motion video of an expanding bullet striking ballistic gelatin. Today, we are happy to ⦠There are .44 Special and .44 Magnum loads to deliver these results, and you have to be careful about it. Discussion in 'Handguns: Revolvers' started by Anthony, Oct 23, 2006. It would have been nice to see the bullet measured and weighed after being fired through just the gel and the gel that had the denim. BB: 594.1 fps, 3.4" Gelatin test data: Impact velocity: 1,848 fps Penetration: 21.1" Retained weight: 231.4 gr Max expansion: 0.711" Min expansion: 0.732" Sorry about the cross section of the wound channel. About the only time we see them in the morgue is during a suicide and, trust me, there's no such thing as an "attempted suicide" with a .44 Magnum. If youâre like most shooters these days, your interest in the revolver as a defensive weapon centers around small frame guns that are easily carried and concealed. The twist rates of .44 Magnum handguns are so fast you could add 100 grains weight to the bullet and still have it stabilize. Admittedly, I was surprised at ⦠I carry a hot 140, myself, gives me 1333 fps/552 ft lbs from a 2" barrel. All information is provided "as is" with all faults without warranty of any kind, either express or implied. Usually see Semi wadcutter, round nose flat point or hollow point. We mix the gelatin with hot water, pour it into molds and refrigerate for at least 72 hours. And if you look hard, you may be able to find gelatin test data, or even photos of tests, for many of the self-defense rounds you might consider using. The magnum-case load, in Special brass, will boost pressures into unsafe territory. Open Food Facts is made by a non-profit association, independent from the industry. This is the third traditional revolver round Black Hills has introduced in the HoneyBadger line, launching the ammunition with a 100-grain .38 Special +P option and the latter introducing a 160-grain .44 Magnum round. Episodes. Ballistic gelatin test of Sig Sauer .44 magnum 240gr V-Crown. Think itâs impossible for handgun hollow points to possess adequate penetration without expanding? .44 mag Winchester 240 gr JSP fired from Marlin 1894 carbine into calibrated gelatin and calibrated tactical rain water. Brassfetcher does not mention the distance for this test. A few days ago, we released the results of our epic self-defense ammo ballistic gelatin project. Clips. RIFLE BALLISTICS. The ultimate goal was to gather muzzle-velocity data on both firearms, and then gather target-velocity data to see if the gain at the muzzle carried enough velocity 25 yards away to really matter once it hit the target. The ordnance gelatin results can be seen in the accompanying table and all loads exceeded the FBIâs minimum penetration depth of 12 inches. 44 Magnum. The rounds were fired from a 4.25â³ Smith & Wesson Model 69 Combat Magnum revolver. I hope you enjoy the video and thanks for watching! We fired factory .45 Colt ammo from two revolver makes with different twist rates and barrel lengths. Win a Dirty Harry 44 Magnum S&W Model 29 Revolver. .44 Special.44 Mag.45 ACP ('08).45 ACP ('15).45 Colt.45 Super.460 Rowland.223 Rifle Acknowledgements. Episodes. We took my .44 magnum Super Red Hawk, the Winchester Dual Bond Jacketed Hollow Point Elite .44 REM Mag, 240 grain, and Winchester .44 REM Mag, 240 grain, Jacketed Soft Point out to ⦠A chronograph was set up in from of the target. This series is a long experiment testing powder coated cast lead hollow point bullets made from various alloys and fired at various velocities. Clips. Test gun: Glock 42 w/ Conversion bbl. .44 Magnum | Close Focus Research - Ballistic Testing Services Related products. Regardless of bullet weight or design, they plow through bone and tissue with ease. This is Knox gelatin in its powder form as itâs being mixed 1 part gelatin to 9 parts hot water. However, when this argument comes up, it almost never consists of apples-to-apples testing. Shortcuts.22 LR.22 Magnum.25 ACP.32 ACP; 9mm Makarov.380 ACP.32 S&W Long.32 H&R Magnum.327 Federal Magnum; Project Overview. The .357 Magnum was collaboratively developed over a period in the early to mid-1930s by a group of individuals in a direct response to Colt's .38 Super Automatic.At the time, the .38 Super was the only American pistol cartridge capable of defeating automobile cover and the early ballistic vests that were just beginning to emerge in the post-World War I "Gangster Era." Moderator; Sharpshooter; Posts: 7891; 10mm, when you care enough to send only the best!! Is that what happened here? For years, we have heard that handguns are less lethal and less effective for defense than rifles. I first tested velocity on my range through a four-inch Smith & Wesson Model 19, which would have been a typical handgun for either load back in the day when Barry Manilow was making buckets of money with his hit "Mandy." It was well received, with the differences in .22 Long Rifle,.38 Special,.357 Magnum and .44 Magnum penetration clearly demonstrated. On the other hand, the .357 Magnum can prove to be a vastly more emphatic killer than some of our more recent low velocity tactical rifle cartridge designs although the latter have superior trajectories. . So, the Ten is not the death ray some believe compared to the big-bore magnum revolvers. Thereâs just something about .429-inch diameter bullets (the .44âs true bore size) which imparts excellent stabilityâa desirable trait for hunting guns. Ah, the .44 Magnum. Stephen Camp (may he rest in peace) published a wonderful review of this round available on the web at his hi-powers - - handguns site that is still up and running. Even the old 44 WCF was round nose flat point. Thread Status: Not ... good stuff for hunting. As for expansion, the 44 Magnum from Barnes did exceptionally well. 44 Magnum. Test media: 10% Clear Ballistics Gel. In our tests, the 45 Long Colt over-penetrated, going approximately 24â³ into our ballistic gelatin. 10mm vs. .357 mag ballistic gelatin test. As for expansion, the 44 Magnum from Barnes did exceptionally well. The .44 Magnum boasts greater bullet weights for deep penetration combined with a wider frontal area as an aid to low velocity killing. As a reference point, Winchesterâs generic 240 grain jacketed soft-point .44 Magnum load penetrates 30 inches in gel with a large temporary stretch cavity. No, it weighs 225 grains because that is all Hornady needed for expansion and penetration, and a lighter bullet with that shape will have a plenty flat trajectory. The 180 grain stuff was never intended for self defense in .357 magnum handguns. The 44 Magnum made it through one complete 16â³ gel block and stopped just as it pierced the second block. In tests, the DRT 85 grain 9mm bullet penetrates semi-hard barriers like sheetrock, plywood, car doors, bone and most glass, then still performing well passing through clothing and into the gelatin test block. Clear Ballistics Gel is calibrated to 10% ballistics gel density. During the test, the chronograph reported errors [â¦] Expansion is fine if your target is no more dangerous than a deer. Widenerâs Reloading and Shooting Supply provided us with some ammunition to evaluate. 1. Leverlution not withstanding. However, when this argument comes up, it almost never consists of apples-to-apples testing. My Marlin was incredibly ammo sensitive until recently. Otherwise, rely ⦠Ammunition: Hornady .357 Magnum 135gr Critical Duty FTX. Since the very beginning of the series on pocket pistols that we started running on the Lounge (as well as YouTube) in late 2018, I have promising to add some of the smaller handgun calibers to our ballistic gelatin test project. Over the years I have read about how devastating the Glaser Safety Slug is in its potent .44 Magnum loading yet the only test I have ever seen was a single plastic gallon water jug...and that was eye opening indeed. 44 Magnum: HP-GC: 180: 899: 1500: 44 Magnum: JHP: 180: 899: 1500: 44 Magnum: HCWC: 200: 750: 1300: 44 Magnum⦠Super Vel rounds were offered in these calibers: .380, .38 Special, .357 Magnum, 9mm, .45 ACP and .44 Magnum. 10 Percent Ballistic Gelatin. 246-grain LRN at 660 fps from a 4-inch revolver was so stable in gelatin that it produced wound volumes that were slightly less than the unstable .38 Spl. 44 Magnum Ammo. 44 Magnum Ammo. Ways to Watch: Download CarbonTV on any of your favorite devices. Remington Ammunition HD9MMD Ultimate Defense 9mm Luger +P 124 gr Brass Jacket Hollow Point (BJHP) 20 Bx/ 25 Cs $ 23.20 Read more Buffalo Bore Ammunition 24J/20 Subsonic 9mm Luger Subsonic 147 gr Full Metal Jacket Flat Nose (FMJFN) 20 Bx/ 12 Cs Neither The High Road nor any of its directors, members, managers, employees, agents, vendors, or suppliers will be liable for any direct, indirect, general, bodily injury, compensatory, special, punitive, consequential, or incidental damages including, without limitation, lost profits or revenues, costs of replacement goods, loss or damage to data arising out of the use or inability to use this forum or any services associated with this forum, or damages from the use of or reliance on the information present on this forum, even if you have been advised of the possibility of such damages. Gold Dot (23973) 1319: 10.0+ 0.382: 239.8: 4.0: 10 *-Distance from muzzle to ballistic gelatin block. MCgunner, Aug 28, 2014 Follow Watch Later Comments Share Facebook Twitter Pinterest Email Next Up. Which caliber will make it through the most boards? Test barrel length: 4 in (102 mm) (vented)Source(s): Federal,3 DoubleTap Ammunition4 The .357 S&W Magnum (9x33mmR), or simply .357 Magnum, is a revolver cartridge created by Elmer Keith, Phillip B. Sharpe,5 and Colonel D. B. Wesson5 of firearms manufacturer Smith & Wesson, and Winchester.67 It is based upon Smith & Wesson's earlier .38 Special cartridge. In our tests, the 45 Long Colt over-penetrated, going approximately 24â³ into our ballistic gelatin. You simply donât need heavier bullets to inflict catastrophic damage to the target when 100% of the energy is absorbed by that target. ... *-Distance from muzzle to ballistic gelatin block. This test is with a 40 grain Remington Power Soft Point, one of my favorite hunting cartridges. A big step up from these rounds, however, is the vaunted .454 Casull cartridge, which takes care of business when an increase in stopping power is desired. EDUCATION 101. â⬢ Rifling twist rate can affect in-tissue stability. The carbines make for useful farm tools and compact hunting rifles while handguns are guaranteed to put an ear to ear grin on any shooters face. Hornady's new magnum loads are hot stuff. To test something like a .45-70 Government requires two of these monster blocks. A deeper and wider wound channel than any, save one, solid 10mm in these tests. The world has seen enough bloody conflicts to confirm this claim. We ordered a truckload of synthetic ballistics gelatin blocks from Clear Ballistics and tested 117 hollow-point loads in the four most popular self-defense calibers: .380 ACP, 9mm, 40S&W, and .45 ACP. I well remember a high school project I observed in the mid 1970s in which Janie Hughston, daughter of pistolsmith T.N. With penetration of 23 inches, this makes the 44 magnum a poor choice for personal defense in an urban setting in my opinion, because your bullets may easily pass through the target and strike an innocent bystander. Cartridges Impact Velocity (ft/sec) Maximum Penetration Depth (inch) Expansion (inch 2) Bullet Weight (grain) Barrel Length (inch) Distance * (feet) Federal: 240gr. In comparison, a 115 grain 9mm traveling at 1,250 fps is 399 foot pounds. Immediately prior to the terminal test, I shoot a five shot velocity and point of impact test string from 8 feet over a Competition Electronics ProChrono Digital chronograph. Although there are others not listed here that some people use for self-defense, the ones most commonly used are .380 ACP, .38 Special, .357 Magnum, .44 Special, .44 Magnum, .45 Colt, 9mm Luger, .40S&W, .45 ACP, and .357 SIG for handguns. lb Muzzle Velocity ft/sec. Bullet weight, however, is greater with the .44, and since bullet weight is the second factor in kinetic energy, the nod would have to go to the .44. Consolidated test results: https://docs.google. Usually itâs somebody comparing a 5.56mm to a 9mm. 9mm Makarov (9x18mm) Ballistic Test Results. LRN. Shell Shockâs NAS3 9mm Cases. I might mention that my 44 magnum Mountain Gun isnât all that comfortable shooting heavy factory loads. A massive test of self-defense ammo with ballistic gelatin and a treasure trove of data for shooters. Using a foot-pounds of energy calculator at Bear Tooth bullets, that comes up to 899 foot pounds. 20 Percent Ballistic Gelatin. Autoplay Recommendations. SIG P320 Ervin testing ballistic gelatin with the Sig Sauer P320 pistol. Distance: 10 feet. I was surprised to see the bullets that went through the denim travel farther than without the denim. Usually when brassfetcher tests a rifle they test at 50 yards. Would you carry a 44 mag for urban self-defense? â https://www.pewpewtactical.com/glock-g45-review/ A special thanks to Underwood Ammunition! CHECK OUT PEW PEW TACTICAL! .44 Smith and Wesson Special ballistic test. The fact any .44 Magnum will chamber and shoot milder .44 Specials gave it the final advantage over the .41 in the market place. Follow Watch Later Comments Share Facebook Twitter Pinterest Email Next Up. 2. The bullet weighs 225 grains and has a spitzer shape with a soft polymer tip in it. 1. 44 Spl, Penta Hollow Point, BHN 8.7, Bare Gel (PC HP Test) Universal Reloading Die Wrench from S3 RELOAD. 44 Magnum (1115 fps), Large Hollow Point, BHN 8.0, Bare Gel (PC HP Test) Save Your Brass â XAegis Brass Catcher. But like all cartridges, the .44 Magnum has its strengths and limitations. The Special-case load, in magnum brass, will under-deliver velocity. Of the six rounds that were measured, the average velocity was 1,299 feet per second. .44 Caliber cartridges are also inherently accurate. Author Topic: Gelatin test results (Read 107824 times) Intercooler. COOL STUFF : 25 ACP 32 ACP 327 Magnum 380 ACP 9mm Luger 357 Magnum 357 SIG 38 Special 38 Super 40 S&W 10mm Auto: 41 Magnum 44 Magnum 44 Special 45 ACP 45 GAP 45 Colt 454 Casull 460 Magnum 480 Ruger 50 AE 500 Magnum: 223 Remington 243 Winchester Evan at stoppingpower.net fired the .44 special DPX bullet out of a 2" Taurus snub and achieved 12.5" penetration through ballistic gelatin, but we don't know the velocity. Load More Seasons 1. A chronograph was set up in from of the target. False Confessions. Our buddies over at The Firearm Blog shoot some 44 magnum Sig Sauer 240 grain V-Crown jacketed hollow point ammo into ballistic gel. Last month, I left you with a shocking revelation: In 1974, the Dallas Crime Lab where I The .44 Smith and Wesson, based off the .44 Russian was introduced in 1907 for the Smith and Wesson New Century Revolver. I recently had the opportunity to test the .44 Magnum version. Might have something to do with the overall length as well as a carry over from rifles as the WCF was loaded in lever guns. of #2400 and #358429 in .38 Special, fired from a 4" S&W N-frame heavy duty exited the 1 metre length gelatin block, and perforated a 2x12" timber angled behind the block to deflect penetrating rounds into a water tank below, and instead riccocheted ⦠It was clearly stated that the material was mixed to 10% of ⦠... Has anyone actually shot the Blue or Silver versions of this load into ballistic gelatin or hunted game with them? With similar ballistics and accuracy of the .44 Russian using the then new smokeless propellant. The mixture ratio of 10% gelatin is 1 part Knox gelatin and 9 parts water.